3.5 DOHC engine issues
Posted: Mon Aug 30, 2010 12:02 pm
Hi everyone.
I am technically disadvantaged, so I need pointers from the people in the know, please. Have looked through the various threads, but I cannot seem to "marrry" the engine symptoms with those mentioned in other threads.
Bought my Paj LWB blister fender Feb last year, 165k, engine was redone due to piston through the block. According to me the engine was doing fine(ish), have power, but lacking somewhat as I expected it to have even more oomph though. Heavy on fuel like you cannot believe! Then the front oil seal at the crankshaft blew. Took it in for repairs, and the mechanic told me that the "crank shaft sensing blade" is suspect as it have other holes drilled in it and he did not trust the situation. So he fitted a brand new crank shaft sensing blade. Since then the engine is less powerful than a 1600 cc engine! He re-checked the timing belt and timing. All fine according to him. Mechanic says it is ECU.
Discussions with various people pointed to ECU-related problems, although no engine management light comes on ever. Took it to SAC, they re-checked the timing and timing belt, confirmed that it is correct, also said ECU. Needless to say, I had a SAC chip installed. Motor is doing wonders now, however, between idle and 1000 rpm (when the chip kicks in) the engine is still extremely rough. Fuel consumption before and after the chip is unchanged. Battling to do real slow crawling below 1000 rpms, because the engine either pulls itself dead on a "definitely not serious" incline or does not react when I step on the accelerator. Takes literally a second or two before the engine responds. The moment the revs fall below 1000, the engine battles. When the chip is unplugged, this erratic behaviour is carried on over the 1000 rpm mark and the engine is back to 1600 engine territory.
Before I take out the ECU to have it checked (at a small fortune), can you give me some pointers where to start looking for possible other sources of the problem(s)? I had someone check all the electrical components' resistences, wattages, volts, etc, and it seems to be fine. Which confirms no lighting up of the engine management light.
Questions: What precisely is the function of the "crank shaft sensing blade", and can it be fitted in more ways than one? From what I could see, no, it cannot, but I am not sure. I.e. can it be that the machanic has indeed fitted the new one incorrectly?
I still feel that the motor is underpowered by at least 15Kw. The dyno measured 92 Kw on the rear wheels after the chip was fitted vs 62 Kw before!
Any ideas? Or is it the ECU that has effectively packed up? I know that the chip can only do so much from an in-efficient ECU.
Thank guys, your input is highly appreciated.
I am technically disadvantaged, so I need pointers from the people in the know, please. Have looked through the various threads, but I cannot seem to "marrry" the engine symptoms with those mentioned in other threads.
Bought my Paj LWB blister fender Feb last year, 165k, engine was redone due to piston through the block. According to me the engine was doing fine(ish), have power, but lacking somewhat as I expected it to have even more oomph though. Heavy on fuel like you cannot believe! Then the front oil seal at the crankshaft blew. Took it in for repairs, and the mechanic told me that the "crank shaft sensing blade" is suspect as it have other holes drilled in it and he did not trust the situation. So he fitted a brand new crank shaft sensing blade. Since then the engine is less powerful than a 1600 cc engine! He re-checked the timing belt and timing. All fine according to him. Mechanic says it is ECU.
Discussions with various people pointed to ECU-related problems, although no engine management light comes on ever. Took it to SAC, they re-checked the timing and timing belt, confirmed that it is correct, also said ECU. Needless to say, I had a SAC chip installed. Motor is doing wonders now, however, between idle and 1000 rpm (when the chip kicks in) the engine is still extremely rough. Fuel consumption before and after the chip is unchanged. Battling to do real slow crawling below 1000 rpms, because the engine either pulls itself dead on a "definitely not serious" incline or does not react when I step on the accelerator. Takes literally a second or two before the engine responds. The moment the revs fall below 1000, the engine battles. When the chip is unplugged, this erratic behaviour is carried on over the 1000 rpm mark and the engine is back to 1600 engine territory.
Before I take out the ECU to have it checked (at a small fortune), can you give me some pointers where to start looking for possible other sources of the problem(s)? I had someone check all the electrical components' resistences, wattages, volts, etc, and it seems to be fine. Which confirms no lighting up of the engine management light.
Questions: What precisely is the function of the "crank shaft sensing blade", and can it be fitted in more ways than one? From what I could see, no, it cannot, but I am not sure. I.e. can it be that the machanic has indeed fitted the new one incorrectly?
I still feel that the motor is underpowered by at least 15Kw. The dyno measured 92 Kw on the rear wheels after the chip was fitted vs 62 Kw before!
Any ideas? Or is it the ECU that has effectively packed up? I know that the chip can only do so much from an in-efficient ECU.
Thank guys, your input is highly appreciated.